WordPress 4.9.3, $_COOKIE, and session_start(): Why did this solution also affect the COOKIE superglobal?
As a software developer, you've likely encountered situations where a seemingly simple code change can have unexpected effects on your web application. This was the case with the WordPress 4.9.3 update, which involved changes to the $_COOKIE
and session_start()
functions. While the primary intent of these changes was to address specific issues, it also led to an impact on the COOKIE
superglobal.
In this article, we'll dive into the technical details behind this phenomenon and explore why the solution to one problem can sometimes create new challenges.
The WordPress 4.9.3 Update
The WordPress 4.9.3 update, released in February 2018, included a fix for a security vulnerability related to the handling of cookies. Specifically, the update addressed an issue where the $_COOKIE
superglobal was not being properly sanitized, potentially leading to security risks.
To mitigate this vulnerability, the WordPress development team introduced changes to the way cookies are handled in the $_COOKIE
superglobal. These changes were intended to ensure that cookie data is properly sanitized and secured, reducing the risk of potential attacks.
The Unexpected Impact: Caching and Cookie Behavior
However, the solution to the security issue inadvertently affected the behavior of the COOKIE
superglobal in a way that many developers found unexpected. The problem arose due to the complex interplay between caching, HTTP headers, and cookie handling in web applications.
Here's a breakdown of what happened:
-
Caching Behavior: When a web page is first loaded, the browser typically caches the response, including any cookies that were set. This caching allows the browser to display the same page quickly when the user revisits the URL, without having to make a new request to the server.
-
Header Changes: As part of the WordPress 4.9.3 update, the developers made changes to the HTTP headers sent by the server. Specifically, they introduced new headers that instructed the browser to check with the server before displaying the cached version of the page.
-
Cookie Handling: The changes to the $_COOKIE
superglobal, while intended to address the security vulnerability, also affected how the browser handled cookies. When the browser checked with the server before displaying the cached page, it included the cookies in the request, expecting the server to handle them accordingly.
The combination of these factors led to a situation where the browser's caching behavior and the server's cookie handling were no longer in sync. This manifested in various ways, such as users seeing stale data or experiencing unexpected behavior when interacting with the website.
Understanding the Subtle Interplay
To better understand the issue, let's consider a more detailed example:
Imagine you have a WordPress-powered website that displays personalized content based on the user's cookie preferences. Before the 4.9.3 update, the process would typically go like this:
- The user visits the website for the first time, and WordPress sets a cookie in the user's browser.
- The browser caches the page, including the cookie.
- When the user revisits the same page, the browser simply displays the cached version, including the previously set cookie.
However, after the 4.9.3 update, the process changes slightly:
- The user visits the website for the first time, and WordPress sets a cookie in the user's browser.
- The server sends HTTP headers instructing the browser to check with the server before displaying the cached version of the page.
- When the user revisits the same page, the browser includes the cookie in the request to the server.
- The server then processes the cookie and generates the appropriate personalized content.
The key difference is that in the updated scenario, the browser is instructed to check with the server before displaying the cached version of the page. This means that the server has the opportunity to process the cookie and generate the correct personalized content, rather than simply serving the cached version.
Implications and Recommendations
The changes introduced in the WordPress 4.9.3 update highlight the importance of understanding the complex interplay between web technologies, such as caching, HTTP headers, and cookie handling. While the primary intent was to address a security vulnerability, the solution had a broader impact on the behavior of the COOKIE
superglobal.
For developers working with WordPress or similar web applications, it's essential to be aware of these types of subtle interactions and their potential impact on your application's behavior. Here are some recommendations:
-
Thoroughly Test Updates: When implementing updates or changes to your web application, always thoroughly test the impact on your application's functionality. This includes testing edge cases and unexpected scenarios, such as the one described in this article.
-
Understand Caching Behavior: Familiarize yourself with how caching works in web applications and the various HTTP headers that can influence caching behavior. This knowledge will help you anticipate and address potential issues related to caching and cookie handling.
-
Monitor and Analyze: Closely monitor your application's performance and user behavior after implementing changes. Use tools like Flowpoint.ai to analyze user behavior, identify any issues, and generate recommendations to improve your application's overall performance and user experience.
By staying informed about the complex interplay between web technologies and being proactive in testing and monitoring your application, you can better navigate challenges like the one encountered with the WordPress 4.9.3 update. This will help you deliver a more reliable and responsive web experience for your users.
Get a Free AI Website Audit
Automatically identify UX and content issues affecting your conversion rates with Flowpoint's comprehensive AI-driven website audit.